TLDR
- Peter Brandt and Jurrien Timmer of Fidelity presented conflicting Bitcoin price forecasts through their banana chart models.
- Brandt criticized Timmer’s chart, calling it “food from Aruba,” and suggested Bitcoin may drop to $42,000 before a rebound.
- Timmer’s Bitcoin model expects a $60,000 support level and a subsequent rise towards a new all-time high of $290,000.
- Brandt emphasized that Bitcoin’s price cycle could follow historical patterns, indicating further downward movement.
- Despite the disagreement, both Brandt and Timmer agree on Bitcoin’s long-term potential, though their short-term outlooks differ.
Veteran trader Peter Brandt and Fidelity’s Jurrien Timmer shared contrasting Bitcoin projections through two banana-shaped chart models this week. Brandt pointed to an imminent downturn in BTC’s price while Timmer suggested an upcoming bullish wave. Their conflicting outlooks triggered renewed discussion around the now-trending Bitcoin Banana chart narrative.
War of the Bitcoin Banana Chart
Peter Brandt reignited debate on Wednesday with his Bitcoin Banana chart forecasting a possible drop near $42,000 before recovery. He posted on X, referring to Fidelity’s Jurrien Timmer’s version as “food from Aruba,” suggesting disagreement with the projection. Brandt claimed Timmer was “playing around” with his version of the chart.
Hello @TimmerFidelity
Interesting that you are playing around with your own version of the Bitcoin Banana $BTC although whereas my forward look calls for a narrowing, yours calls for broadening
Your food from Aruba looks fabulous 🥩🥩🥩 pic.twitter.com/GpKw568xwy— Peter Brandt (@PeterLBrandt) February 11, 2026
The chart structure compares Bitcoin’s historical market cycles using curved formations resembling a banana. Brandt’s version shows BTC hovering close to the “banana peel,” an area from which it previously rebounded. He argued that BTC could soon enter this lower range as in past cycles.
In contrast, Timmer’s chart, titled “Bitcoin’s Road to Maturity,” outlines a corrective phase with $60,000 as a possible bottom. It forecasts a breakout into a sixth wave with a long-term target near $290,000. Brandt shared the chart but questioned the optimism shown in Timmer’s short-term expectations.
Brandt emphasized that his chart has accurately marked Bitcoin tops and bottoms in earlier cycles. On February 5, he highlighted the potential for BTC to bottom out around $42,000. He added the phrase “hop, skip, and jump” to describe a rebound that might follow such a dip.
Fidelity’s Projection Faces Pushback
Jurrien Timmer, Fidelity’s Director of Global Macro, shared a chart showing a broad upward trajectory for BTC after a correction. He indicated that Bitcoin is progressing steadily, with a major bullish wave on the horizon. His chart points to $60,000 acting as a support level.
Timmer’s forecast extends beyond the current corrective phase and expects growth aligned with past wave patterns. He included historical models to support the upcoming Wave 6 expansion. The chart suggests a gradual climb to a projected high of $290,456.
Brandt did not dispute the long-term price level but questioned the rapid expansion implied in the short term. He criticized Timmer’s optimistic curve, saying it lacked alignment with Bitcoin’s current consolidation. Their disagreement centers on timing, not necessarily final price targets.
The Fidelity chart has gained attention for offering a smoother ride for BTC holders. However, Brandt remains unconvinced that the asset has completed its downward phase. Both models rely heavily on historical repetition but differ in interpretation.
Diverging Outlooks Stir Debate on Bitcoin Banana
The ongoing debate has drawn attention to the Bitcoin Banana chart as traders analyze potential moves. Brandt insists that BTC may still test previous lows before any bullish rally begins. He sees a possible pattern repeat, though he warns of no certainty.
Timmer’s view aligns more with gradual maturity in Bitcoin’s market behavior. His model shows reduced volatility and longer-term stability. The $60,000 base offers a less steep drop than Brandt’s estimate.
Brandt’s outlook narrows focus on short-term price action, preferring caution near current levels. He warns that a premature upside could break historical patterns. His chart implies BTC must revisit the banana peel to complete the cycle.
